Monday, December 15, 2008

Activity 1.4: The Argumentative Essay

Thesis: Do Hamlet's actions and words prove his own lack of sanity?
Reason: Yes, literally.
Example: In Shakespearean literature, an insane character exhibits behavior that goes against societal norms, sometimes endangering those around them or even themselves.
Example: His soliloquies, which are based off of death and tragedy... not something so openly talked about by a sane person at that time. (3.1.64-98)
Reason: Yes, clinically/psychologically/medically...
Example: Hamlet exhibits traits characteristic to mania and schizophrenia, as well as bipolar disorder and several other psychotic disorders.
Example: Hamlet's grief sets in so deeply that his thoughts of sorrow and suicide get the better of him, fueling his hate and drive for revenge. (within 3.1.64-98)
Reason: Yes, legally.
Example: Hamlet cannot be held responsible for his actions because he is legally insane, showing know appreciation of the nature and quality of his wrong-doing.

No comments: